Michigan Supreme Court to decide fate of 350 juvenile lifers
March 6, 2014 | MPRN Governor Rick Snyder just signed a new law this week to update Michigan’s sentencing policies to reflect that Supreme Court decision. But that doesn’t settle what happens to Matthew Bentley.
“I was 15 years old and being in a rush to be a man. I made a mistake and now 14 years later I’m still in prison, missing out on everything I was in a rush to get.”
That is Bentley from a podcast provided by the American Civil Liberties Union. He shot and killed a woman during a break-in at her home. He says he would take it all back if he could.
“I sometimes think about what could have happened, what could have been different. There’s a possibility I could have went down a different path, had I gotten some better advice, had I been shown a better way, had I actually had a role model.”
Because of the US Supreme Court decision, juveniles convicted of murder or aiding and abetting in a murder now must have a hearing that takes into account their circumstances – abuse or neglect, how culpable they were in the crime, things like that. The court said the absence of that made automatic life without parole for juveniles cruel and unusual punishment.
Now, the ACLU and three juvenile lifers are suing the state. They say if automatic life without parole is unconstitutional going forward, then that same logic should apply to those earlier 350-plus cases, some of which date back to the early 1960s.
Kimberly Thomas is a law professor with the University of Michigan’s Juvenile Justice Clinic. She says we’ve learned a lot in recent years about shortcomings in how the legal system deals with juveniles. She says teenagers are often poor clients.
“It’s hard to get them to understand the choices that they’re making. Especially when faced with what might be good plea bargains, they just aren’t making good choices.”
Thomas says representing minors is a unique set of skills that most defense attorneys just don’t have. And she says the proof of that is how often juveniles get tougher sentences than adults involved in the same murders, even when the juvenile was only an accessory to the crime.
The decision in this case before the state Supreme Court will likely turn on a legal nuance.
To win, the juvenile lifers have to show the US Supreme Court decision represents a substantive change in their legal rights. The state, on the other hand, is arguing that it’s not – that this was a procedural decision. It has no bearing on their guilt or innocence, and that means there’s no responsibility to go back and correct their sentences.
But this is not a nuance for another group of people closely following this case.
“We’re the innocent, and we deserve some kind of closure to this…”
Jody Robinson’s brother was murdered by a 16-year-old and a 19-year-old. And she says don’t call that a “mistake.” Robinson gets angry, visibly upset, when she hears that teens are sentenced to –quote- “die” in prison.
“They weren’t sentenced to die – period. They were sentenced to live the rest of their life in prison. They’re living. They’re not dead, and there’s a big difference between the two.”
Robinson says families like hers will never get their loved ones back -- and changing the rules now would deny them the measure of peace that once came with finality in their cases.
For the Michigan Public Radio Network, I’m Rick Pluta in Lansing ListenDownload
More WGVU News
Friday Hop candy delivers flavor without the hangover GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. December 19, 2014 | WGVU Today is National Hard Candy Day. The ingredients for making hard candy is basic; syrup, citric acid, food coloring and flavoring. And for kids young and old it’s the flavor that matters. WGVU discovered a one-of-a-kind candy taste earlier this year at the American Homebrewers Association Conference held at Grand Rapids’ DeVos Place. ListenDownload US Senate race in Michigan drew $56M in spending LANSING, Mich. December 19, 2014 | AP The race for U.S. Senate in Michigan drew more than $56 million in spending from the campaigns and outside supporters. Snyder signs bills to streamline some courts LANSING, Mich. December 19, 2014 | AP Gov. Rick Snyder has signed legislation designed to streamline the district court system in Michigan by creating more flexibility for magistrates. Snyder signs bill to expand nuisance abatement LANSING, Mich. December 19, 2014 | AP Gov. Rick Snyder has signed legislation to expand local governments' power to file nuisance complaints against homeowners and businesses suspected of illegal activity such human trafficking or gun crimes. Michigan Lottery sales reach record $2.6 billion LANSING, Mich. December 19, 2014 | AP Michigan Lottery ticket sales have reached a record $2.6 billion in the 2014 budget year. Tighter Internet sales tax collections are OK'd LANSING, Mich. December 19, 2014 | AP Amazon.com and other online stores will have to collect Michigan's sales tax on purchases under legislation headed to Gov. Rick Snyder. 168-year-old Grand Rapids house restored as treatment center GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. December 19, 2014 | AP A 168-year-old Grand Rapids mansion has been renovated for use as a private treatment center for women with alcohol and drug addictions. Cyberbullying legislation sent to Gov. Snyder LANSING, Mich. December 19, 2014 | AP Michigan school districts would have to include cyberbullying in their anti-bullying policies and report bullying data to the state under legislation going to Gov. Rick Snyder. Michigan voters to decide road funding tax hike LANSING, Mich. December 19, 2014 | AP A proposed tax hike aimed at improving Michigan's transportation infrastructure and schools is heading to voters. Authorities: Man arrested in 1990 beating death GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. December 19, 2014 | AP Authorities say a 56-year-old man has been arrested in the 1990 beating death of a 23-year-old in Grand Rapids. 11 charter authorizes remain at-risk of suspension LANSING, Mich. December 19, 2014 | AP The Michigan Department of Education has decided to keep the status of 11 of the state's charter school authorizers at-risk of possible suspension. Michigan gets $349,000 in cell 'cramming' deal LANSING, Mich. December 19, 2014 | AP Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette says the state will receive $349,000 as part of a $90 million national settlement with cellphone company T-Mobile.