SCOTUS to consider challenge to MI affirmative action ban
October 15, 2013 | MPRN Jennifer Gratz was here in Washington a decade ago. Her attorneys argued before the Supreme Court that the University of Michigan’s affirmative action policy violated her right to a seat in a classroom and not just a spot on a waiting list. Back then, the court delivered a split decision. It threw out the point system the university used to deny Gratz a first-round admission. But it also allowed the limited use of affirmative action to help recruit minorities. “Personal victory for me,” says Gratz. “Principled victory for the University of Michigan. I followed that up by starting a ballot initiative.”
That ballot initiative was Proposal Two of 2006. It amended the state constitution to outlaw the use of race- or gender-conscious policies in university admissions and public employment.Now, the amendment is being challenged by a critics who say it enables discrimination and disables universities’ efforts to recruit and admit minority students. It’s up to Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette to defend the amendment.
“We’re not discriminating against anybody,” says Schuette.
“If anything, we’re discriminating against discrimination.” Schuette says he’s confident he’ll win. He says the Supreme Court has already moved in that direction by setting parameters around the use of affirmative action.
“Preferences are barely constitutional,” says Schuette. “That’s just the state of the law.”But opponents say Michigan’s ban on race-conscious admissions has set back diversity efforts at places like the University of Michigan.“Only 4.7 percent of the undergraduate student population is African American. Only 4.7 percent is Latino. Point-one-nine is Native American. And considering that we live in a diverse state where 14 percent of the state population is African American,” says PhD student Jessica Moorman. “This is a state institution, a public institution, an institution that’s clearly not serving all of the citizens of the state.”
The opponents’ case is that Proposal Two created a two-tiered system for people who want to go to the governing board of U-of-M or any other public institution seeking to right an unfairness. They say athletes, children of alumni and others can expect to have their concerns addressed. They say complaints by students from racial minorities are treated differently.
“If you are a student of color, you would have to pass a constitutional amendment to have your concerns raised or acted upon,” says UM psychology professor Rosario Cabello. She is one of the collection of U-of-M faculty members and former students who are plaintiffs challenging the amendment.Cabello says minority students and would-be students should not have to launch a ballot campaign to have their complaints addressed.
But win or lose, Jennifer Gratz says she does not expect the Supreme Court decision will settle the controversy surrounding affirmative action.“I have no doubt that regardless of what happens at the Supreme Court, this battle will continue on for a long time. And I didn’t always believe that was true, but I’ve come to the realization that there isn’t going to be a day where either side can stand up and say, We’ve won. This is over.”
More WGVU News
Yesterday Kent County Health Department scores high national honor Grand Rapids MI September 18, 2014 | WGVU After more than two years of preparation, the Kent County Health Department has been recognized by the Public Health Accreditation Board (PHAB) for its effectiveness, efficiency and outreach. State, local initiatives target skilled labor demand September 18, 2014 | WGVU Talking points of two Grand Rapids-area events focused on college and skilled trade investments. ListenDownload Rep. Amash opposes U.S. arming Syrain rebels to fight ISIS September 18, 2014 | WGVU President Barack Obama's request for congressional backing to train and arm rebels battling Islamic State militants in Syria is halfway home after easy approval by the GOP-controlled House Wednesday. In West Michigan, two Republican U.S. Representatives voted against the resolution; Congressman Bill Huizenga of Zeeland and Justin Amash of Cascade Township. WGVU spoke with Representative Amash about his concerns arming Syrian Rebels. ListenDownload U.S. Rep. Huizenga opposes U.S. arming Syrain Rebels to fight ISIS September 18, 2014 | WGVU President Barack Obama's request for congressional backing to train and arm rebels battling Islamic State militants in Syria is halfway home after easy approval by the GOP-controlled House Wednesday. In West Michigan, two Republican U.S. Representatives voted against the resolution; Congressman Justin Amash of Cascade Township and Bill Huizenga of Zeeland and. WGVU spoke with Representative Huizenga about his concerns arming Syrian Rebels. ListenDownload Authorities: 5th grader with gun had list of names Kingsley MI September 18, 2014 | AP Authorities say a fifth-grade boy found with a loaded pistol at a middle school in Michigan's northern Lower Peninsula had created a list of classmates' names. Michigan teen admits arson over arranged marriage Lansing MI September 18, 2014 | AP A Michigan teenager has admitted she set a fire in her house while her parents were sleeping because she didn't want to get engaged in an arranged marriage. Grand Rapids university gets $1 million stained glass Grand Rapids MI September 18, 2014 | AP A Christian university in Grand Rapids has hired a Danish artist to construct four stained glass windows valued at $1 million for its new chapel.
Moves urged to target Michigan car insurance fraud Lansing MI September 18, 2014 | AP A task force established by Secretary of State Ruth Johnson is recommending proposals to crack down on auto insurance fraud. Governor seeks federal aid in flooding recovery Lansing MI September 18, 2014 | AP Michigan is seeking a help from Washington for residents and businesses affected by last month's severe flooding. Census figures show Michigan incomes rise in 2013 September 18, 2014 | AP The U.S. Census Bureau says household incomes in Michigan rose 1.7 percent in 2013 after years of decline. Work near on Indiana berm to block Asian carp September 18, 2014 | AP Work could start this fall on building a nearly 2 mile-long earthen berm through a northeastern Indiana marsh considered a possible pathway for Asian carp to reach the Great Lakes. Supreme Court suspends Detroit judge Sanders Detroit MI September 18, 2014 | AP A Detroit judge has been suspended without pay by the Michigan Supreme Court.
Michigan, Stanford get $10M for election studies Ann Arbor MI September 18, 2014 | AP The National Science Foundation has awarded more than $10 million to researchers at the University of Michigan and Stanford University to conduct a series of surveys on political participation and vote choice in the 2016 presidential election. Hearses to parade through Hell (Michigan) Hell MI September 18, 2014 | AP Dozens of Michigan hearse enthusiasts will show off their casket-carrying cars during a parade through Hell. Ex-Gov. Milliken backs Democrat Totten for AG September 18, 2014 | AP Former Republican Gov. William Milliken is backing Democrat Mark Totten for state attorney general, saying the Michigan State University associate law professor's experience makes him "highly qualified" for the office. Supreme Court edits opinion in parole dispute Lansing MI September 18, 2014 | AP The Michigan Supreme Court has changed the last sentence of a June opinion, an edit that could lead to the release of a prison inmate in an unusual case about the powers of governors. Democrats call for hold on new charter schools September 18, 2014 | MPRN Democrats at the state Capitol are calling for a moratorium on new charter schools until there are rules that ensure more transparency and accountability.
We have more from Rick Pluta