WGVU donate banner

Thursday, January 29, 2015

Public Media Catagories
PBS Link Create Link WorldView Link NPR Link Real Oldies Link wgvu
All Things Considered
WGVU Top Story

New NHL drafting model suggested by GVSU researcher


Patrick Center
July 4, 2013 | WGVU   The Grand Rapids Griffins are the 2013 American Hockey League Champions. On the ice a show of size, speed and desire.  

Much of the roster is stocked with players drafted by its parent club, the Detroit Red Wings, through the National Hockey League’s annual draft.   

“In general, the higher you’re drafted the more likely you are to succeed in the NHL.”  

That’s the overwhelming belief. Researcher Robert Deaner took a closer look at the past 26 NHL drafts to discover teams could do a better job picking future all-stars if they’d make their selections based on a player’s date of birth.  

“Yeah it’s been there since the 1980’s that the NHL teams have been making this mistake, this bias we call it, in drafting. They’re over selecting their relatively older players or under selecting their relatively younger players, whichever way you want to look at it it’s the same thing.”  

Deaner’s recently released study called “Born at the Wrong Time: Selection Bias in the NHL Draft” focused on Canadian youth hockey and its impacts on player development and ultimately the draft.  

Of Canadian skaters drafted since 1980 there’s a trend Deaner and his colleagues Aaron Lowen and Stephen Cobley uncovered.  

“So Guys born in the first three months, they are 36 percent of the draftees. Guys born in the last three months are only about 14 percent. So they’re not being drafted nearly as much. But those 14 percent they produce as many All-Stars as the 36 percent from the first three months.”  

It’s called relative age effect and in Canadian hockey it has long-term effects.  

“The kids that look the best are the ones that are a little bit bigger, a little bit faster a little bit more developed. And the ones that are typically better like that are usually the ones that are a little bit older than the ones that are, you know, 12 years and nine months as opposed to 12 years and one month of age.”  

Those slightly older kids are selected to play on the better teams, receive more ice time and get more attention in practice while those relatively younger players don’t and begin to lose confidence.  

At a Grand Rapids Griffin’s practice I asked the team’s Canadian born center if he buys into the theory?  

“I’m Riley Sheahan, 21-years old born on December 7th 1991. I was drafted 21st overall by the Detroit Red Wings...Obviously there are statistics to prove that being born earlier in the year helps but I never knew or really heard of this theory but I guess it makes sense.”  

But Tom McCollum who was born in December of 1989 and drafted 30th overall in the 2008 draft says there’s more to it than the cosmic wheel of fate. 

 “As far as over the course of a lifetime I feel like there are a lot of other factors that could affect things rather than when you were born.” 

 “Unique players are born around the calendar year certainly this study I’ll keep it in mind for the future...I’m Jiri Fischer, Detroit Redwings Director of Player Development. Born on the last day of July 1980.”  

That makes him a ‘tweener. He was drafted 25th overall by the Red Wings in the 1998 draft.  

“Relative age does make certainly some difference in some cases but when you look through the youth some of the talented players play three years up. And that’s talking about the Gretzky’s and Jamir Jager’s and then there are the majority of others that obviously it does make a difference maybe in early years to be a little bit older than others.” 

When it comes to return on investment Deaner maintains those players born later in any given year outperform their peers based on the career milestone of 600 games played.  

“If you’ve played that long you’ve probably made an All-Star game or two. You’re a solid player. I think maybe about 15 percent of guys born in the last few months of a year make it there, 15 percent of the draft picks. Whereas it’s only about seven percent of the guys born in the first three months. The relatively younger guys are always much more likely to make it to the career milestones.”  

Deaner argues there’s an underdog effect. The relatively younger players may have a quiet demeanor but worker harder to achieve greatness.

The study is a stepping stone to other areas where relative age effect may have long-term impacts. Deaner and his team are looking into education implications and age bias in the classroom?

Patrick Center, WGVU News.

More WGVU News
TIF reform expected in 2015 legislative session
  January 29, 2015  |  WGVU  Experts expect tax increment finance reform efforts to continue in 2015.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Snow, sleet, freezing rain contribute to Michigan wrecks
Kalamazoo MI  January 29, 2015  |  WGVU  Snow, sleet and freezing rain are combining to create slippery road conditions across parts of Michigan and leading to traffic wrecks.    
Cargo plane slides off Ford airport taxiway; no injuries
Grand Rapids MI  January 29, 2015  |  WGVU  Officials say no one was injured when a cargo plane slid off a taxiway at Gerald R. Ford International Airport in western Michigan.    
Detroit homeowners to see lower property tax assessments
Detroit, MI  January 29, 2015  |  WGVU  Mayor Mike Duggan has announced about three quarters of residential properties in Detroit will see at least a 10 percent tax reduction on upcoming notices.    
Conviction tossed in case of man who acted as his own lawyer
Ferndale MI  January 29, 2015  |  WGVU  A man who insisted on acting as his own lawyer has persuaded the Michigan appeals court to throw out his conviction - because a judge didn't fully explain the risk of acting as his own lawyer.    
Advisers to get training on helping owners protect forests
Lansing MI  January 29, 2015  |  WGVU  State experts will provide training for professional land managers in Michigan with a goal of helping private forestland owners avoid practices that cause soil erosion and degrade water quality.    
Detroit NAACP to celebrate installation of elected officers
Detroit, MI  January 29, 2015  |  WGVU  U.S. Rep. John Conyers will administer the oath of office to NAACP Detroit branch president the Rev. Wendell Anthony during the civil rights organization's installation ceremony.    
GRAAHI Holds Several Health Care Enrollment Workshops
Grand Rapids MI  January 29, 2015  |  WGVU  The deadline for federal health coverage under the Affordable Care Act is fast approaching. Experts say there’s still much confusion about the marketplace and cost of insurance.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Police dept offers office for Craiglist safety
  January 29, 2015  |  WGVU  A West Michigan police department proposes a unique way to keep residents safe on Craigslist.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Poll reveals Michigan voters favor Prop. 1 sales tax increase until details are revealed
  January 29, 2015  |  WGVU  A recently released poll indicates likely Michigan voters would vote ”yes” to raise the state sales tax and fix crumbling roads and bridges. Reveal the Proposal 1 details, and voters polled say “no.” WGVU finds out why.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Report: officer shot in Wyoming
  January 29, 2015  |  WGVU  A police officer was shot in Wyoming this afternoon following an altercation.    
Some lawmakers want to give voters alternative to roads ballot proposal
  January 29, 2015  |  MPRN  Some state lawmakers want to pass a legislative alternative to the May ballot proposal to boost road funding.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Governor: Not concerned about early ballot polls
  January 29, 2015  |  MPRN  Governor Rick Snyder says he’s not worried about early polls that show the road funding proposal on the statewide May ballot is in trouble.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download

Ford recalls cars, vans for door latch and seat belt trouble
Dearborn, MI  January 28, 2015  |  WGVU  Ford is recalling more than 221,000 cars and vans to fix problems with door latches and seat belts.    
Michigan school mourns loss of students killed in car crash
Ypsilanti MI  January 28, 2015  |  WGVU  The men's basketball team at Eastern Michigan University has honored two students who were killed in a car accident over the weekend.    
Michigan agencies collecting travel data from households
Traverse City MI  January 28, 2015  |  WGVU  Two Michigan agencies are teaming up in an effort to project future travel needs and establish transportation priorities for the next two decades.    
Community meetings to give updates on Detroit rail project
Detroit, MI  January 28, 2015  |  WGVU  Residents and businesses in Detroit's Midtown and downtown areas can receive updates on construction of a $140 million light rail project.    
Porcupine Mountains taking artist-in-residence applications
Lansing MI  January 28, 2015  |  WGVU  Artists looking for inspiration in the great outdoors can apply to spend some quality time at Porcupine Mountains Wilderness State Park.    
Muskegon public safety emphasizes full-time value
  January 28, 2015  |  WGVU  A Muskegon public safety transition values full-time fire fighters over part-time employment.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
GRPD now accepting applications for Explorer Program
Grand Rapids MI  January 28, 2015  |  WGVU  A new program from the Grand Rapids Police Department aims to better the police-community relationship, starting at a young age. It follows the Chief’s commitment to open doors of communication.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
RV maker, automaker plan expansion projects in Michigan
LANSING, Mich.   January 28, 2015  |  AP  Officials say recreational vehicle maker Forest River Manufacturing and automaker Toyota are planning Michigan expansions.   
Report shows House committees were top direct donors in 2014
LANSING, Mich.  January 28, 2015  |  AP  A new analysis says campaign committees for Democrats and Republicans in the Michigan House of Representatives were the biggest direct donors in state-level elections in 2014.   
16 year olds could pre-register to vote under bill at state Capitol
  January 28, 2015  |  MPRN  Michigan teens would be able to pre-register to vote under a proposal in Lansing.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Economist says May ballot has $100 million loophole
  January 28, 2015  |  MPRN  An economic study says the May ballot proposal to raise the state sales tax could also cost Michigan taxpayers 100 million dollars more in federal income taxes.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download

Eastern Michigan teams plan tributes to basketball player
Ypsilanti MI  January 27, 2015  |  WGVU  The athletic department at Eastern Michigan University has planned tributes for a women's basketball player killed in a car crash over the weekend.    
Ex-Detroit emergency manager Orr to speak at econ club event
Detroit, MI  January 27, 2015  |  WGVU  Former state-appointed emergency manager Kevyn Orr will speak at a Detroit Economic Club event.    
Michigan township officials gather for annual conference
Grand Rapids MI  January 27, 2015  |  WGVU  More than 1,100 elected and appointed township officials and staff are expected in Grand Rapids this week for the Michigan Townships Association Conference.    
Police increase patrols at Kalamazoo College after robberies
Kalamazoo MI  January 27, 2015  |  WGVU   Police say they have increased their presence at Kalamazoo College following five armed robberies on campus.    
Michigan State Police seek OK to use aerial drone statewide
Detroit, MI  January 27, 2015  |  WGVU  State police are seeking authorization to use an aerial drone across Michigan to photograph vehicle crash scenes and give a bird's-eye view of other emergency situations.    
Grand Rapids among top global growth economies
  January 27, 2015  |  WGVU  A recent Brookings Institution report puts Grand Rapids in the top 100 fastest-growing economies in the world.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
70th anniversary of Auschwitz liberation remembered by child survivor
  January 27, 2015  |  WGVU  Tuesday marks the 70th Anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz. It was January 27, 1945 when Russian troops entered the Nazi death camp. Tova Friedman, one of the few Auschwitz child survivors was there. Earlier this month she visited Grand Rapids and spoke with WGVU.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
GRPD body cams to start in March
  January 27, 2015  |  WGVU  A pilot program for Grand Rapids Police Department body cameras is in the works.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Education bills a top early focus for Senate Republicans
LANSING, Mich.   January 27, 2015  |  AP  Republicans who control Michigan's Senate plan to make education legislation a top priority early this year.   
Michigan Democrats say they're holding off on Iran sanctions
DETROIT   January 27, 2015  |  AP  Michigan's Democratic U.S. senators have told President Barack Obama they'll hold off for now on a bill to increase sanctions against Iran to allow negotiations on nuclear weapons a chance to work.   
Meekhof: GOP frustration has subsided after Snyder vetoes
LANSING, Mich.  January 27, 2015  |  AP  The leader of the Michigan Senate says frustration over Gov. Rick Snyder's recent vetoes of gun, e-cigarette and forestry bills has subsided among Republicans   

Police investigating body found in New Buffalo Township
New Buffalo Township, MI  January 26, 2015  |  WGVU  Michigan State Police are investigating the death of a woman found near railroad tracks in Berrien County.    
Michigan authorities arrest 3 suspected of taking snow plows
Byron Twp MI  January 26, 2015  |  WGVU  Authorities say they have arrested three people suspected of stealing snow plows in western Michigan.    
Kalamazoo girl, 4, saves pregnant mom's life during seizure
Kalamazoo MI  January 26, 2015  |  WGVU  A Kalamazoo mother credits her 4-year-old daughter with saving her life after suffering from an epileptic seizure while nine months pregnant.    
Campground fees rise this year at Michigan state parks
Lansing MI  January 26, 2015  |  WGVU  Fees at state-operated campgrounds in Michigan are going up this year to cover higher costs and pay for maintenance projects.    
2 stabbed at Muskegon Heights' Brooks Correctional Facility
Muskegon Heights MI  January 26, 2015  |  WGVU  The Michigan Department of Corrections says two inmates were stabbed on the same day in what appear to be unrelated attacks.    
AAA Michigan: Gas prices rise 3 cents in past week to $1.96
Dearborn, MI  January 26, 2015  |  WGVU  AAA Michigan reports statewide gas prices have increased by about 3 cents a gallon within the past week.    
Grand Rapids Cancels Flights To East Coast
Grand Rapids MI  January 26, 2015  |  WGVU  A number of flights out of Grand Rapids Ford International Airport are cancelled today in anticipation of what’s being described as a "crippling and potentially historic" storm in the Northeast.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
'Beer City' brews malt house start-up
  January 26, 2015  |  WGVU  If you live or play near Beer City, you probably know where to find your favorite pint. The question of how it gets there led to a business model for one local entrepreneur.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Michigan, China to work together on fisheries, aquaculture
LANSING, Mich.  January 26, 2015  |  AP  Officials from Michigan and China plan to work together on developing advancements in fisheries and aquaculture.   
Gov. Snyder, in rare visit, outlines civil rights priorities
LANSING, Mich.   January 26, 2015  |  AP  Gov. Rick Snyder has made a rare visit to outline his priorities at a meeting of the Michigan Civil Rights Commission in Lansing.   
State Senate panel to take up animal abuse bills Tuesday
  January 26, 2015  |  MPRN  State lawmakers will try again to crack down on animal cruelty in Michigan.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Snyder lays out civil rights plans at commission meeting (
  January 26, 2015  |  MPRN  Governor Rick Snyder addressed the Michigan Civil Rights Commission today    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download

Kalamazoo students defend district amid textbook criticism
Kalamazoo MI  January 23, 2015  |  WGVU  Several Kalamazoo students turned out at a school board meeting to dispute allegations by a man who held a hunger strike to highlight what he believes is a problem with the district's textbook policies.    
3 contestants win annual Pure Michigan Hunt contest
Lansing MI  January 23, 2015  |  WGVU  Three contestants have been named winners of the sixth annual Pure Michigan Hunt and will receive a number of licenses and more than $4,000 worth of gear.    
Michigan men arrested at tunnel not big threat, cops say
Detroit, MI  January 23, 2015  |  WGVU  Police in Windsor, Ontario, say two Michigan men accused of bringing illegal weapons into Canada from Detroit didn't pose a national security threat.    
Boy who brought loaded gun to Michigan school gets probation
Traverse City MI  January 23, 2015  |  WGVU  An 11-year-old boy who brought a loaded gun to his northern Michigan school has been placed on probation for two years.    
Community Health Systems announces deal with Metro Health
WYOMING, Mich.   January 23, 2015  |  WGVU  A Tennessee-based company is taking a significant financial interest in Wyoming-based Metro Health system.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
625-pound man sentenced to prison in fake bomb threat case
GRAND RAPIDS, Mich.  January 23, 2015  |  WGVU  A 625-pound western Michigan man has been sentenced to at least a year-and-a-half in prison for a fake bomb threat.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Health officials confirm first Michigan measles case in 2015
LANSING, Mich.  January 23, 2015  |  AP  State health officials have confirmed the first reported case of measles in Michigan this year and say it may be associated with a recent outbreak at California's Disneyland theme park.   
Significant drop in union membership in first full year of right to work
  January 23, 2015  |  MPRN  Michigan unions saw a significant drop in membership during the first full year of the state’s right-to-work law.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download

Listen Live to WGVU-AM
Listen Live to WGVU-FM
Follow us on Twitter
WGVU News Page Sponsored by:
Home    Privacy Policies    Contact WGVU    GVSU.edu    PBS.org    NPR.org
Copyright 1997-2015 | WGVU is a service of Grand Valley State University | GVSU is an EO/AA institution