WGVU donate banner

Friday, March 6, 2015

Public Media Catagories
PBS Link Create Link WorldView Link NPR Link Real Oldies Link wgvu
All Things Considered
WGVU Top Story

ProductionTax Credit set to expire impacting local wind energy industry

wind power


Patrick Center
December 31, 2012 | WGVU  

“We had a 600 foot German freighter five stories tall with wind blades and wind tower components. It was quite an impressive site.”

I walk along Muskegon’s Mart Docks with Arn Boezart, who heads up the Michigan Alternative Renewable Energy Center. He tells me this is where seven more ocean freighters each the length of four or five football fields offloaded their cargo.

“During that time had daily convoys that left here moving wind blades one day and wind turbine towers the next day.”

As this leading wind energy expert tells the story, he had plenty of questions.

“I thought now why would we be bringing wind turbine towers and blades from Korea and Germany respectively?”

Clearly, they could be manufactured in the United States - and Michigan in particular - saving the estimated $7 million trans-ocean freight charge. Boezart began making calls to learn the folks behind the BeeBe Wind Farm project - located just north of Lansing near Ithaca – had moved its construction schedule from 2013 to 2012. Why would they do that? Call it a race against the clock to take advantage of a wind energy subsidy. Congress has failed, at least so far, to extend the federal Production Tax Credit set to expire December 31st.

“Congress has a long history of providing tax incentives for energy development spurring new technologies.”

The American Wind Energy Association has produced this video informing decision makers in Washington.

“Because of the uncertainty developers are not making plans and U.S. manufacturers are not receiving orders impacting the wind industry workforce.”

“I would estimate that numbers somewhere in the neighborhood of 40 to 50,000 jobs have been lost in the United States in the last 12 months.”

That’s David Slikkers, he’s Principal of Holland-based, Energetx a maker of composite wind turbine blades.

Slikkers explains the longer congress went without extending the PTC the greater the number of wind projects have been dialed back. Slikkers says the operators of the BeeBe Wind Farm will reap the tax credit reward by meeting the December 31st deadline. But it comes at a cost to local companies like Energetx competitively bidding to fulfill the blade order.

“Absolutely for 2013 we just couldn’t do it quite for 2012. The Production Tax Credit influenced an opportunity. Now I’m not here to debate, I’ll say the spilled milk. I’m saying there’s significant amount of opportunity and investment missing here in our country as a result of them not taking action.”

For Energetx, a contract with the turbine maker for the BeeBe project would have netted 100 to 150 new jobs more than doubling its current workforce.

“The wind industry is not an infant industry anymore. It’s been around for a number of years and it’s high time it stands on its own to feet.”

Thirty four years taxpayers have been propping it up says Dr. Bonner Cohen of The National Center for Public Policy Research. If congress does act, he says it will mark the seventh time the PTC has been extended.

“At what point in the future will these subsidies end?”

At a cost of more than $12 billion a year.

“Why is it that the gas and oil industries have had 93 years of uninterrupted subsidy? I don’t know of any industry that has had such a boom in profits, in billions, over the last five years as the gas and oil companies.”

“But the oil industry does not need the subsidy to survive. If somebody want to do away with the tax credit and you’ve got congress to go along with it, well and good. After all the country is $16 trillion in debt and cuts are going to have to start somewhere.”

The American Wind Energy Association argues over the past four years the PTC is responsible for increasing 40 percent of new power generation installations in the U.S and Europe is wind. Outstripping both coal and nuclear. 

“The PTC has fostered dramatic growth of the wind industry in the U.S. It has created 78,000 wind industry jobs and it has enabled suppliers and manufacturers to increase domestic content.”

Without it a 2011 Navigant study indicates total wind supported jobs will drop by nearly half, from 78,000 in 2012 to 41,000 in 2013.

And as we walked the Mart Docks in Muskegon, Arn Boezart tells me there needs to be a national energy strategy in place that provides market certainty for U.S. entrepreneurs, investors and manufacturers…Production Tax Credit or not.

“So whether we do that in this country with tax credits or whether we do it with other offsets. Whether we do it with a national commitment, there’s a variety of ways to skin the cat as they say. But we clearly need to avoid scenarios like we had here this year where we have to import manufactured goods that we clearly have the capacity to make ourselves.”

More WGVU News
Michigan officials seek comment on wolf management plan
Lansing MI  March 5, 2015  |  WGVU  The Michigan Department of Natural Resources is inviting public feedback on an updated plan for managing the state's gray wolves.    
Muskegon Heights house fire that killed 1 ruled arson
Muskegon Heights MI  March 5, 2015  |  WGVU  Investigators have determined someone purposely set a fire that killed a woman squatting in a vacant Muskegon Heights home.    
Washington man eyeing 'organ house' in West Michigan
Grand Rapids MI  March 5, 2015  |  WGVU  A retired bus driver from suburban Seattle hopes to move across the country so he can live in a Grand Rapids home containing a massive pipe organ.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Officials: Man dies following house fire in western Michigan
Muskegon Heights MI  March 5, 2015  |  WGVU  Officials say a man has died following a house fire in western Michigan.    
Gilda's LaughFest holds opening night paper crown record bid
Grand Rapids MI  March 5, 2015  |  WGVU  An annual festival of laughter in western Michigan is trying to set a record for the most people wearing paper crowns.    
Community forum tackles free speech and seperation of church and state
  March 5, 2015  |  WGVU  A forum is being held Thursday evening addressing freedom of expression and free speech in Ottawa County. It comes in response to Grand Haven officials removing a cross from public display and debate over a bible scripture exhibited in a county park.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Mobility device gives local child new independence
  March 5, 2015  |  WGVU  A local family, a genetic disease with no cure and a team of Grand Valley State University researchers and students come together to create a unique medical device.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
2015 Laughfest Kicks Off Tonight: Seriously Funny
Grand Rapids MI  March 5, 2015  |  WGVU  Let the laughing begin. Today kicks off another Gilda’s Club LaughFest. Lots of entertainment coming to West Michigan… big names and local talent alike. There’s even a Guinness Book of World Records event. But, while it’s funny, it’s also serious business.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Holland reports overall drops in crime statistics
  March 5, 2015  |  WGVU  Holland’s Department of Public Safety says 2014 police incidents were at a 10-year low.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
GVSU automotive suppliers symposium forecasts record year for U.S. automakers
  March 5, 2015  |  WGVU  The U.S. auto industry is on course for setting production and sales records this year. It’s a far cry from 2009 when U.S. automakers struggled during the depth of the Great Recession. How will this impact local supplier and consumers?    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Senate panel passes ban on plastic beads polluting lakes
INDIANAPOLIS   March 5, 2015  |  AP  An Indiana Senate committee unanimously passed a bill that would ban the sale and manufacture of popular toiletries and cosmetics containing tiny plastic particles that environmentalists say are polluting water resources.   
Michigan's high school graduation rate goes up to 79 percent
LANSING, Mich.  March 5, 2015  |  AP  Michigan's high school graduation rates have increased for the third consecutive year, moving up to nearly 79 percent statewide.   
46 school districts expected to wipe out, reduce deficits
LANSING, Mich.   March 5, 2015  |  AP  Michigan's education chief has told lawmakers in Lansing that a number of the 56 school districts in the state with budget deficits are expected to be out of the red or cut into them this year.   
State superintendent calls for moratorium on new charter schools
  March 5, 2015  |  MPRN  State Superintendent Mike Flanagan is calling for a moratorium on new charter schools in Michigan.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download

Officials: Baby died at in-home day care in western Michigan
Kentwood MI  March 4, 2015  |  WGVU  Officials say an infant died at an in-home day care center in western Michigan after the operator failed to get him proper medical attention.    
Egelston Township scraps porta-potty restrictions
Egelston Twp., MI  March 4, 2015  |  WGVU  Local officials have rescinded a zoning ordinance amendment restricting the use of portable toilets in Egelston Township.    
State education board chooses 6 superintendent semifinalists
Lansing MI  March 4, 2015  |  WGVU  The State Board of Education has invited six candidates to publicly interview for the state superintendent job next week.    
Michigan Democrats seek 20 percent renewable power by 2022
Lansing MI  March 4, 2015  |  WGVU  Democrats are calling for Michigan to double the amount of electricity that comes from wind and other renewable sources.    
Researchers discover Asian carp native predators
  March 4, 2015  |  WGVU  A new study finds there are a number of native predators gobbling up Asian carp. The study has attracted a lot of attention. Are there are enough predator fish to shrink or eliminate the bighead and silver carp populations?   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Grand Rapids City Officials Review LGBT Ordinance Language
Grand Rapids MI  March 4, 2015  |  WGVU  Grand Rapids City Officials are looking to perhaps update ordinance language. A review is underway looking at language used in an amendment regarding LGBT protections to the city’s non-discrimination ordinance. Some say the language change would simply keep up with the times.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Muskegon partnership proposed to lower chlamydia rates
  March 4, 2015  |  WGVU  Muskegon County officials review a proposed partnership to help address what one health expert calls a “chlamydia epidemic”.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
New judge to get update on loose ends in Detroit bankruptcy
DETROIT   March 4, 2015  |  AP  The Detroit bankruptcy case is returning to court with a different judge and some loose ends that need to be tied up.   
Michigan’s film incentives move closer to their demise in state Legislature
  March 4, 2015  |  MPRN  A bill to eliminate Michigan’s film incentives is advancing in the state House.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download

City adds sexual orientation to non-discrimination ordinance
East Grand Rapids, MI  March 3, 2015  |  WGVU  A city in western Michigan is adding sexual orientation and gender identity to an existing non-discrimination ordinance on housing and employment.    
Prosecutor: Officers acted in self-defense during shootout
Wyoming MI  March 3, 2015  |  WGVU  A prosecutor has determined two police officers acted in self-defense during a fatal shootout with a suspect in a Grand Rapids suburb.    
Former teacher accused in illicit photos case gets probation
St. Joseph, MI  March 3, 2015  |  WGVU  A former southwestern Michigan middle school teacher accused of taking cellphone pictures of a student's underwear has been sentenced to five years of probation.    
Lawmakers to be briefed on problem-plagued computer system
Lansing MI  March 3, 2015  |  WGVU  Michigan officials are preparing to update lawmakers on a problem-plagued computer system that is intended to aid child welfare efforts.    
Federal agency awards $5.5M in rental assistance to Michigan
Lansing MI  March 3, 2015  |  WGVU  The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development is awarding more than $5.5 million in rental assistance to help Michigan residents with disabilities.    
City may add sexual orientation to non-discrimination rules
EAST GRAND RAPIDS, Mich.  March 3, 2015  |  WGVU  East Grand Rapids is considering language to amend its housing and employment non-discrimination ordinance to include sexual orientation and gender identity.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
IRS Expands Tax Center Test To Grand Rapids
Grand Rapids MI  March 3, 2015  |  WGVU  The IRS has added Grand Rapids to its list of cities that offers appointment based tax help at its Tax Assistance Centers. The move is part of a test the IRS is doing to see if appointments work better than a walk-in system. The goal is to see if taxpayers avoid the long lines and wait times. The Grand Rapids and Marquette offices are the only two in Michigan.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Michigan officials seek frog, toad survey volunteers
LANSING, Mich.  March 3, 2015  |  WGVU  Michigan officials are seeking volunteers to help with the state's annual frog and toad survey, which is entering its 20th year.   
Strong US economy helps automakers plow through snowy weather and boost sales
DETROIT  March 3, 2015  |  AP  Freezing temperatures and drifts of snow likely took a small bite out of U.S. auto sales last month, but most automakers are still reporting gains thanks to the strong economy.   
Workers: Computer system slowing child protection efforts
LANSING, Mich.  March 3, 2015  |  AP  Michigan caseworkers say a new computer system that launched 10 months ago is riddled with problems that are hampering their ability to protect vulnerable children.   
House committee to take up adoption agency bills
  March 3, 2015  |  MPRN   A state House committee could vote tomorrow on bills to shield faith-based adoption agencies from having to serve LGBT couples if the US Supreme Court legalizes same-sex marriage.    
Lawmakers considering penalties for failing to call 911 when someone is in danger
  March 3, 2015  |  MPRN  State lawmakers are debating whether someone should face penalties if they fail to act when they know someone else is in danger.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download

Work starting on facilities for more Fermi 2 protection
Frenchtown Township, MI  March 2, 2015  |  WGVU  Construction starts this week on two facilities to provide more backup protection for Fermi 2's nuclear reactor and used fuel pool in the event of a natural disaster.    
Authorities find problem with recent drugged driving law
Lansing MI  March 2, 2015  |  WGVU  Authorities say there's a problem with a recent Michigan law allowing police to conduct a preliminary roadside analysis for drugs and other intoxicating substances in addition to alcohol.    
Damage estimate climbs in vandalism at Michigan ski resort
Ann Arbor MI  March 2, 2015  |  WGVU  The general manager of a ski resort vandalized by University of Michigan students estimates the total damage is about four times the original estimate.    
AAA Michigan: Gas prices rise 11 cents in past week to $2.42
Dearborn, MI  March 2, 2015  |  WGVU  AAA Michigan reports statewide gas prices have increased by about 11 cents a gallon within the past week.    
Girl, 3, critical after getting stuck outside in deep cold
Lansing MI  March 2, 2015  |  WGVU  Lansing police say a 3-year-old girl sustained critical injuries from hypothermia after she apparently got out of her family's apartment in the bitter cold and then couldn't get back in through a locked door.    
Women social workers face leadership barriers
  March 2, 2015  |  WGVU  Social work in the United States was created by women. It would be reasonable to assume women hold the majority of leadership positions. Yet, that’s not the case. Two researchers from Western Michigan University’s Grand Rapids campus have revealed the barriers female social workers face. WGVU spoke with the authors of “Falling Silent: Analyzing the Voices of Women Leaders in the Social Work Profession.”   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Officials seek to boost food assistance at farmers markets
East Lansing MI  March 2, 2015  |  WGVU  Officials want to boost the use of food assistance benefits at farmers markets in Michigan.    
East Grand Rapids reviews non-discrimination policy
  March 2, 2015  |  WGVU  East Grand Rapids officials introduce a new non-discrimination ordinance tonight.    
125,000 Dollar effort planned to help study Port of Muskegon
Muskegon MI  March 2, 2015  |  WGVU  A $125,000 effort is planned to help study the best way to develop the Port of Muskegon in western Michigan.    
Supporters push for paid sick leave statewide
  March 2, 2015  |  WGVU  Advocates of paid sick leave renew efforts for a statewide policy.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Grants aid Port of Muskegon development study
  March 2, 2015  |  WGVU  West Michigan’s largest natural deep-water port is the recipient of $125,000 in grants to fund study of possible development options.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Michigan could bypass healthier school fundraising rules
LANSING, Mich.  March 2, 2015  |  AP  Legislation introduced in the state House and Senate would offer flexibility to raise money at least three times a week by selling snacks in Michigan schools now banned under federal guidelines.   
Michigan pays $4.9M for membership in Common Core group
LANSING, Mich.  March 2, 2015  |  AP  Michigan is paying $4.9 million this school year to continue its membership in a group that develops standardized tests aligned with national Common Core education standards.   
Snyder names West Michigan school chief as education adviser
LANSING, Mich.  March 2, 2015  |  AP  Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder has named an intermediate school district leader from western Michigan as his new education policy adviser.   
Skilled trades, Prop 1, state sup’t search big topics at governor’s education summit
  March 2, 2015  |  MPRN  Governor Rick Snyder is getting some tough questions about the May roads ballot proposal at his education and economic summit this week in Detroit.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Michigan appeals federal wolf decision
  March 2, 2015  |  MPRN  Michigan is appealing a federal judge’s decision to restore endangered species protections to the gray wolf. Wildlife groups filed the lawsuit after Michigan and other states adopted wolf hunting seasons.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download

Listen Live to WGVU-AM
Listen Live to WGVU-FM
Follow us on Twitter
WGVU News Page Sponsored by:
Home    Privacy Policies    Contact WGVU    GVSU.edu    PBS.org    NPR.org
Copyright 1997-2015 | WGVU is a service of Grand Valley State University | GVSU is an EO/AA institution