WGVU donate banner

Monday, March 2, 2015

Public Media Catagories
PBS Link Create Link WorldView Link NPR Link Real Oldies Link wgvu
All Things Considered
WGVU Top Story

WGVU election profile: Proposal 4


Patrick Center
October 31, 2012 | WGVU  

Before you can decide if the Michigan Home Health Care Amendment is a good or bad idea, you need to know the history leading up to it appearing on the ballot.

Back in 1981, the state established The Adult Home Help Program. The Michigan House Fiscal Agency says it, “Provides payment for personal care services to Medicaid-eligible aged, blind, and disabled persons which enable them to remain in independent living arrangements…part of Michigan’s overall strategy to increase community-based alternatives and reduce dependence on institutional care settings such as adult foster care and nursing homes.”

In 2004, during the Governor Jennifer Granholm administration, the Michigan Department of Community Health and the Tri-County Aging Consortium created the Michigan Quality Community Care Council. It provided the elderly and disabled a registry of potential home health care workers.

While a strategy and registry is a good idea, Wendy Block, who’s Director of health Policy & Human Resources for the Michigan Chamber of Commerce explains that in 2006 it turned into a scheme to organize home health care workers orchestrated by the Service Employees International Union.

“They used that organization as a tool to organize and extract nearly $30 million before it was all said and done in union dues from these home health care workers.”

Governor Rick Snyder says most of these caregivers are either friends or family members. When I spoke with the Governor Monday, he explained he doesn’t like the arrangement that home care providers are also state employees paying union dues.

“I didn’t think that was right. The legislatures didn’t think that was right. We passed a law to discontinue that over time. The union didn’t like that answer so their goal was to put some very narrow special protection in the Michigan constitution to protect this $6 million a year revenue stream.”

The governor says the Michigan Department of Community Health should not be collecting union dues from Medicaid payments – a public subsidy. A federal circuit court judge has since filed an injunction.

“I’m paralyzed from my chest down from a spinal chord injury from 1982. So I’ve been at this for about 30 years.” Scott Heinzman is a Michigan Adapt organizer who says a “Yes” vote on Proposal 4 is a vote for quality care. “For those of us who need in home care work those people are extremely valuable to us but turnover rate is super-high because they get paid so poorly.”

A 2011 Anderson Economic Group report estimates there are 46,000 Home Help providers. Heinzman says some are paid below minimum wage while most estimates say it’s more inline with $8 and $15 dollars an hour. If voters approve Prop 4, home care workers will undergo screening and criminal background checks. Those workers must also receive proper training says Heinzman, “We continue to fight for home-based services while the state continues to spend more than ¾ of its long term care dollars on nursing homes.”

That Anderson Economic Group report finds “The Michigan Home Help program is significantly less expensive than nursing facility care,” estimating “that per beneficiary, the state saves $47,000 annually if a person is diverted from nursing facility care and into home care.”

Wendy Block at the Michigan Chamber doesn’t dispute that because the Michigan Home Help Program has been around for 31 years and will continue regardless of Tuesday’s vote. “The proposal is all about creating new guaranteed revenue streams for the SEIU to spend on their political agenda at the expense of these family health care providers and other home health care providers who will lose a portion of their Medicaid reimbursement….These dollars are intended to reimburse providers for their services not to fund union activities and that is why we are opposed.”

Heinzman argues 29 percent of nursing home residents would prefer the in-home care alternative. He says its time for Michigan residents to make a commitment. “This amendment, if you read the language, commits the state of Michigan in its constitution to in-home, provider directed services which means it will be safer controlling who comes into our houses and not having high rates of turnover. It respects our right to choice. It’s less expensive than institutions and almost everyone who supports it would want it for themselves.”

It’s your decision, your choice, November 6th.

More WGVU News
Fermenta fosters female brewing creativity
  February 27, 2015  |  WGVU  A new women's craft brewing guild makes its mark in Michigan.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Eastpointe man sentenced for selling fake auto insurance
Lansing MI  February 27, 2015  |  WGVU  A 64-year-old Michigan man has been sentenced to one year in jail for selling fake auto insurance certificates.    
State shuts down in-home day care amid death investigation
Kentwood MI  February 27, 2015  |  WGVU  The state has shut down an in-home day care center in western Michigan following the death of an infant who'd recently been cared for there.    
Jury can hear of road rage killing suspect's aggressive past
Howell MI  February 27, 2015  |  WGVU   A judge says a jury can hear testimony that a 69-year-old man accused of a road-rage killing in southeastern Michigan was involved in a similar but non-fatal confrontation previously.    
Compromise plan unveiled for Allied Paper Superfund site
Kalamazoo MI  February 27, 2015  |  WGVU  A $65 million to $70 million compromise plan for cleaning up Kalamazoo's Allied Paper Superfund site has been unveiled.    
Palisades nuclear plant's safety rating to be downgraded
Covert Twp MI  February 27, 2015  |  WGVU  Federal regulators say the safety rating for Palisades nuclear power plant in southwestern Michigan will be downgraded following a violation related to how some workers' radiation doses were monitored and calculated.    
Consumers Energy, Salvation Army Keep Customers Warm
Grand Rapids MI  February 27, 2015  |  WGVU  The Salvation Army and Consumers Energy have joined forces once again to help with energy assistance during the cold winter months. More than a million dollars will help cover the cost of heating bills. We spoke with Salvation Army officials about this effort.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Net neutrality lawsuits, legal issues predicted
  February 27, 2015  |  WGVU  The Federal Communications Commission’s decision to treat the internet as a public utility has a broad impact on consumers as well as business interests. WGVU breaks down some of the details with a local legal expert.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
DeBoer attorney says SCOTUS arguments will focus on children
  February 27, 2015  |  WGVU  Attorneys for the lesbian couple challenging Michigan’s same-sex marriage ban have filed their briefs with the US Suprem e Court. Oral arguments are expected this spring.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
State grant to GRCC helps bridge workforce and employer demands
  February 27, 2015  |  WGVU  Developing a skilled workforce meeting the needs of area employers received a shot in the arm this week when the Michigan Economic Development Corporation awarded Grand Rapids Community College a $2.9 million grant.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Authorities: Woman dies after being hit by semi in Otsego
OTSEGO, Mich.   February 27, 2015  |  AP  Authorities say a woman was fatally struck by a semi-truck after she fell while crossing a street in southwestern Michigan.   
Study to examine Detroit-Lansing-Grand Rapids passenger rail
ANN ARBOR, Mich.   February 27, 2015  |  AP  A study will look at possible new passenger rail service that could connect Detroit, Lansing, Grand Rapids and Holland.   
Michigan, U.S. appealing judge's ruling on Great Lakes wolves
  February 27, 2015  |  AP  Michigan is joining the federal government in appealing a decision that restores legal protections for gray wolves in the western Great Lakes region.   

Kalamazoo Promise celebrating 10th anniversary
Kalamazoo MI  February 26, 2015  |  WGVU  An initiative that awards college tuition to Kalamazoo high school graduates is celebrating its 10th anniversary and nearly 4,000 scholarships.    
Plans move ahead for casino at former horse racing track
Fruitport Twp MI  February 26, 2015  |  WGVU  Plans are moving forward for a casino at a former horse racing track in western Michigan.    
Records: Number of women getting concealed gun licenses up
Lansing MI  February 26, 2015  |  WGVU  Records show an increase in the number of women getting a license to carry a concealed handgun.    
State shuts down in home day care amid death investigation
KENTWOOD, Mich.  February 26, 2015  |  WGVU  The state has shut down an in-home day care in western Michigan following the death of an infant who had recently been cared for there.   
Michigan efforts get $4 million to fight invasive species
LANSING, Mich.   February 26, 2015  |  WGVU  The Michigan Department of Natural Resources says 20 projects are getting more than $4 million as part of efforts to fight invasive species.   
Black History Month: GVSU Couple Create Doors Of Opportunity
Grand Rapids MI  February 26, 2015  |  WGVU  As we round out Black History Month, we check in today with two Grand Valley State University Staff who recently received a “Trailblazer” award. The annual Giants Awards earlier this month recognizes African Americans in the Grand Rapids community. This year, a couple was recognized for their efforts.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
House adopts bills to relax air guns rules
  February 26, 2015  |  WGVU  The state House has adopted legislation that would exempt air-, spring-, and gas-powered guns from Michigan firearms laws.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
State grants boost local college skilled trade programs
  February 26, 2015  |  WGVU  Nearly $13 million has been allocated to four western Michigan community colleges in an effort to bolster the state’s skilled trade programs.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Officials in Grand Rapids seek to boost youth employment
GRAND RAPIDS, Mich.  February 26, 2015  |  AP  Officials in Grand Rapids are taking steps to boost employment opportunities for young people in the city.   
Board considers ballot language for Michigan road fund vote
LANSING, Mich.   February 26, 2015  |  AP  The Board of State Canvassers is meeting to determine the wording of a road funding ballot proposal asking voters if they want to increase the state sales tax.   
Lawmakers seek short-term action to stop Asian carp advance
TRAVERSE CITY, Mich.  February 26, 2015  |  AP  Members of Congress are calling for quick action at a crucial spot in the Chicago area to block Asian carp from reaching the Great Lakes.   
Michigan House votes to carve air guns out of firearms laws
LANSING, Mich.   February 26, 2015  |  AP  The Michigan has finished two days of voting on bills revising how the state regulates gun use and ownership.   
Michigan House delays vote on police cellphone location data
LANSING, Mich.   February 26, 2015  |  AP  The state House is delaying voting on a bill that would require wireless carriers to share cellphone location information with law enforcement during emergencies.   
State Senate sends budget cuts to Gov. Snyder that divert surplus school aid dollars
  February 26, 2015  |  MPRN  Legislation headed to Governor Rick Snyder would divert surplus school aid money to help fill Michigan’s budget hole.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download

GRPD expands youth outreach, summer academy program
  February 25, 2015  |  WGVU  Grand Rapids Police Department officers visited more than two dozen schools to talk with students about law enforcement opportunities. It's a part of strategic recruitment efforts, and something officers say they enjoy.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Delta ends service from Rochester, Minnesota to Detroit
Rochester, Minnesota  February 25, 2015  |  WGVU  Delta Airlines plans to end its daily flight from Rochester, Minnesota to Detroit, Michigan.    
Records: Official urged state not to lease passenger trains
Lansing MI  February 25, 2015  |  WGVU  Records show a local transportation official urged a Michigan agency not to lease passenger trains that are now sitting idle.    
Effort to control deer population near school includes hunt
Dearborn, MI  February 25, 2015  |  WGVU  Deer are being killed near the campus of the University of Michigan-Dearborn as part of an effort to manage the area's deer population.    
Advocates urge Congress not to cut Great Lakes funding
Washington DC  February 25, 2015  |  WGVU  Advocates for the Great Lakes are meeting in Washington, D.C., this week to push for continued funding of cleanup programs and discuss water quality issues such as algae blooms and oil transportation.    
Michigan House considering bills changing gun permit process
Lansing MI  February 25, 2015  |  WGVU  The state House is moving this week on approving a variety of bills changing how gun possession and use are regulated in Michigan.    
Muskegon casino takes step toward becoming reality
  February 25, 2015  |  WGVU  Little River Band of Ottawa Indians files application with Bureau of Indian Affairs   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Black History Month: The Next Generation
Grand Rapids MI  February 25, 2015  |  WGVU  Black History month is nearing its end. We have a couple of profiles to round out the week. Today, we talk with long time Grand Rapids City Commissioner Elias Lumpkins. He says Grand Rapids needs the commitment of young people to continue along the path of progress that’s already in the works.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Muskegon road millage, local fire proposals defeated
  February 25, 2015  |  WGVU  Two Muskegon County tax proposals have been voted down by residents.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Authorities: Bicyclist, 58, dies after being hit by vehicle
PLAINFIELD TOWNSHIP, Mich.  February 25, 2015  |  WGVU  Authorities say a 58-year-old bicyclist had died after being struck by a vehicle in western Michigan.   
Grand Rapids commission renovations approved
  February 25, 2015  |  WGVU  A more than $600,000 facelift for the Grand Rapids City Commission chambers called “unconscionable” by one commissioner receives 6-1 approval.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Grand Rapids Public Museum to open Egyptian exhibition
GRAND RAPIDS, Mich.   February 25, 2015  |  AP  The Grand Rapids Public Museum is preparing to open an exhibition of its collection of ancient Egyptian artifacts.   
Lawsuit challenges photos, fingerprinting of young people
GRAND RAPIDS, Mich.  February 25, 2015  |  AP  A black man who says he was stopped, photographed and fingerprinted by Grand Rapids police despite committing no crime is challenging the practice.   
Volunteers plan alternative to candy-tossing ban at parade
GRANDVILLE, Mich.   February 25, 2015  |  AP  Organizers of a July 4 parade in western Michigan are seeking to avoid a ban on candy-tossing to spectators by having volunteers keep people from getting too close to vehicles along the route.   
Michigan House approves bills changing gun permit process
LANSING, Mich.   February 25, 2015  |  AP  The state House has begun approving a variety of bills changing how gun possession and use are regulated in Michigan.   
U.S. House approves bill to step up fight against toxic algae
TRAVERSE CITY, Mich.   February 25, 2015  |  AP  The U.S. House has voted to require more aggressive federal action to prevent toxic algae blooms from contaminating the Great Lakes and other waterways around the nation.   
New fight at Capitol over film subsidies
  February 25, 2015  |  MPRN  A state House committee held a hearing today on legislation to end Michigan’s big tax breaks for film, TV, and movie projects.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
State House approves overhaul of concealed pistol license approval
  February 25, 2015  |  MPRN  Concealed weapons bills similar to ones Governor Rick Snyder vetoed last month are one step closer to heading back to his desk.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download

Boil water advisory in effect due to broken pipe in Baldwin
Baldwin, MI  February 24, 2015  |  WGVU  The Lake County Central Dispatch has issued a boil water advisory for Baldwin residents.    
Grand Rapids plans $10 million land purchase for green space
Grand Rapids MI  February 24, 2015  |  WGVU  Grand Rapids plans to seek a state grant to make a $10 million purchase of about four acres of property along the Grand River for use as green space.    
Company awarded contract to build Lake Huron research vessel
Lansing MI  February 24, 2015  |  WGVU  State officials say they've awarded a contract for construction of a new vessel to support Lake Huron fisheries research.    
Snow, wind to make travel hazardous in parts of Michigan
Grand Haven, MI  February 24, 2015  |  WGVU  Another round of winter weather is expected to make travel difficult in parts of Michigan as bitterly cold temperatures moderate somewhat.    
Gilda's LaughFest plans opening night paper crown record bid
Grand Rapids MI  February 24, 2015  |  WGVU  An annual festival of laughter in western Michigan is planning an effort to set a record for the most people wearing paper crowns.    
GRPS To Ask Voters For $175 M Tax Proposal
Grand Rapids MI  February 24, 2015  |  WGVU  Grand Rapids Public Schools hopes voters will support a nearly 175-million dollar tax proposal come November. The money would be used for renovations, security and technology.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Grand Rapids chicken ordinance approved
  February 24, 2015  |  WGVU  There’s a new meaning for the term ‘spring chicken’ in Grand Rapids. A pilot program allowing for backyard chickens at city residential properties begins in a couple months.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Grand Rapids Chamber supports Proposal 1
  February 24, 2015  |  WGVU  The Grand Rapids Area Chamber of Commerce explains why its throwing support behind Proposal 1.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
State lawmakers taking another crack at corrections overhaul
  February 24, 2015  |  WGVU  There’s a renewed push in the state Legislature to overhaul Michigan’s corrections system.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
18 community college given $50 million for trades equipment
LANSING, Mich.  February 24, 2015  |  AP  Eighteen Michigan community colleges are receiving $50 million to train students for careers in the skilled trades.   
Snyder cheers bond funding for workforce training programs
  February 24, 2015  |  MPRN  A state board has approved selling bonds to come up with 50 million dollars to help community colleges ramp up their career and technical training.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download

Listen Live to WGVU-AM
Listen Live to WGVU-FM
Follow us on Twitter
WGVU News Page Sponsored by:
Home    Privacy Policies    Contact WGVU    GVSU.edu    PBS.org    NPR.org
Copyright 1997-2015 | WGVU is a service of Grand Valley State University | GVSU is an EO/AA institution