WGVU donate banner

Thursday, July 31, 2014

FacebookFlickrTwitterYouTubeLinkedIn
 
Public Media Catagories
PBS Link Create Link WorldView Link NPR Link Real Oldies Link wgvu
All Things Considered
WGVU Top Story

WGVU election profile: Proposal 4


connectmidmichigan.com

Patrick Center
October 31, 2012 | WGVU  

Before you can decide if the Michigan Home Health Care Amendment is a good or bad idea, you need to know the history leading up to it appearing on the ballot.

Back in 1981, the state established The Adult Home Help Program. The Michigan House Fiscal Agency says it, “Provides payment for personal care services to Medicaid-eligible aged, blind, and disabled persons which enable them to remain in independent living arrangements…part of Michigan’s overall strategy to increase community-based alternatives and reduce dependence on institutional care settings such as adult foster care and nursing homes.”

In 2004, during the Governor Jennifer Granholm administration, the Michigan Department of Community Health and the Tri-County Aging Consortium created the Michigan Quality Community Care Council. It provided the elderly and disabled a registry of potential home health care workers.

While a strategy and registry is a good idea, Wendy Block, who’s Director of health Policy & Human Resources for the Michigan Chamber of Commerce explains that in 2006 it turned into a scheme to organize home health care workers orchestrated by the Service Employees International Union.

“They used that organization as a tool to organize and extract nearly $30 million before it was all said and done in union dues from these home health care workers.”

Governor Rick Snyder says most of these caregivers are either friends or family members. When I spoke with the Governor Monday, he explained he doesn’t like the arrangement that home care providers are also state employees paying union dues.

“I didn’t think that was right. The legislatures didn’t think that was right. We passed a law to discontinue that over time. The union didn’t like that answer so their goal was to put some very narrow special protection in the Michigan constitution to protect this $6 million a year revenue stream.”

The governor says the Michigan Department of Community Health should not be collecting union dues from Medicaid payments – a public subsidy. A federal circuit court judge has since filed an injunction.

“I’m paralyzed from my chest down from a spinal chord injury from 1982. So I’ve been at this for about 30 years.” Scott Heinzman is a Michigan Adapt organizer who says a “Yes” vote on Proposal 4 is a vote for quality care. “For those of us who need in home care work those people are extremely valuable to us but turnover rate is super-high because they get paid so poorly.”


A 2011 Anderson Economic Group report estimates there are 46,000 Home Help providers. Heinzman says some are paid below minimum wage while most estimates say it’s more inline with $8 and $15 dollars an hour. If voters approve Prop 4, home care workers will undergo screening and criminal background checks. Those workers must also receive proper training says Heinzman, “We continue to fight for home-based services while the state continues to spend more than ¾ of its long term care dollars on nursing homes.”

That Anderson Economic Group report finds “The Michigan Home Help program is significantly less expensive than nursing facility care,” estimating “that per beneficiary, the state saves $47,000 annually if a person is diverted from nursing facility care and into home care.”

Wendy Block at the Michigan Chamber doesn’t dispute that because the Michigan Home Help Program has been around for 31 years and will continue regardless of Tuesday’s vote. “The proposal is all about creating new guaranteed revenue streams for the SEIU to spend on their political agenda at the expense of these family health care providers and other home health care providers who will lose a portion of their Medicaid reimbursement….These dollars are intended to reimburse providers for their services not to fund union activities and that is why we are opposed.”

Heinzman argues 29 percent of nursing home residents would prefer the in-home care alternative. He says its time for Michigan residents to make a commitment. “This amendment, if you read the language, commits the state of Michigan in its constitution to in-home, provider directed services which means it will be safer controlling who comes into our houses and not having high rates of turnover. It respects our right to choice. It’s less expensive than institutions and almost everyone who supports it would want it for themselves.”

It’s your decision, your choice, November 6th.



More WGVU News
Yesterday
Kent County voters face crucial library millage next week
Grand Rapids MI  July 30, 2014  |  WGVU  Kent County voters are facing two county wide millage proposals next week. One of them is a renewal and increase combination for the Kent District Library.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Autopsy finds woman died of ligature strangulation
  July 30, 2014  |  WGVU  A medical examiner has found that a pregnant Michigan woman police say was killed by a man she connected with through Craigslist was strangled with a rope, strap or other device.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Personal Property Tax repeal and replacement on August 5th ballot
  July 30, 2014  |  WGVU  It’s up to Michigan voters to approve the repeal of the state’s personal property tax. It will appear on the August 5th ballot as Proposal 1. What is the personal property tax and how will the money lost be replaced?   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Schauer says he'd create tens of thousands of jobs
Watertown Twp MI  July 30, 2014  |  AP   Democratic gubernatorial candidate Mark Schauer has unveiled an economic blueprint he says will create "tens of thousands" of jobs if he defeats Republican Gov. Rick Snyder.   
Fort Wayne GM plant lacks parts, cancels shifts
Fort Wayne IN  July 30, 2014  |  AP  An auto parts shortage has caused the cancellation of several shifts at the General Motors truck assembly plant in Fort Wayne.   
Small cars fare poorly in crash tests
Detroit MI  July 30, 2014  |  AP  The four-door Mini Cooper Countryman was the only one of 12 cars to earn a top rating of "good" in new frontal crash tests.   
Terror threats at chemical plants underestimated
Washington DC  July 30, 2014  |  AP   Congressional investigators say the government is underestimating the threat of a chemical attack on America's densely populated cities and has failed to inspect virtually all of the chemical facilities that it considers particularly vulnerable to terrorists.    
Canada, Michigan name border bridge authority
  July 30, 2014  |  AP  Michigan and Canada have appointed members of an authority to oversee construction of a $2 billion public bridge between Detroit and Windsor, Ontario.   
Lawyer sues GM on behalf of 658 plaintiffs
  July 30, 2014  |  AP  A Texas lawyer has sued General Motors on behalf of 658 people injured or killed in crashes allegedly caused by faulty ignition switches.   
625-lb Michigan bomb threat suspect bedridden
  July 30, 2014  |  AP  A 44-year-old Michigan man charged with making a bomb threat says he can't appear in court because of his weight.   
100+ show up to give input on new standardized test
  July 30, 2014  |  MPRN   Michigan education officials are in the process of finding a new standardized test – again. As Michigan Public Radio’s Jake Neher reports, more than a hundred people were in Lansing today to say what they want out of a new assessment.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download

Tuesday
Community meetings help officials better deal with lead abatement
Grand Rapids MI  July 29, 2014  |  WGVU  Childhood lead poisoning continues to be a problem in West Michigan, just as it is around most of the state. A series of lead poisoning prevention training sessions will help community leaders get a better idea of what needs to be done.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Balyo enters guilty plea
  July 29, 2014  |  WGVU  A former Grand Rapids radio host has pleaded guilty to sexual exploitation and possessing child pornography.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Ex-radio host expected to plea in child porn probe
Grand Rapids MI  July 29, 2014  |  AP  A former host at a popular Christian radio station in western Michigan is expected to plead guilty in a child pornography investigation.   
Testimony to resume in porch slaying trial
Detroit MI  July 29, 2014  |  AP  Testimony is to resume in the trial of a suburban Detroit man charged in the shooting death of a 19-year-old woman on his porch.    
Man walking dog finds abandoned newborn along road
White Cloud MI  July 29, 2014  |  AP  A man walking a dog along a western Michigan dirt road has found a newborn with her umbilical cord still attached.   
Ford raising prices on new F-150
Detroit MI  July 29, 2014  |  AP  Ford is raising the price of its new aluminum-sided pickup truck, but still trying to stay competitive with rivals.   
White House to honor Michigan blueberry producer
Washington DC  July 29, 2014  |  AP   A Paw Paw, Michigan blueberry producer is among 15 "Champions of Change" for agriculture.   
Storms prompt concern about some Michigan crops
Beaver Twp MI  July 29, 2014  |  AP  There's concern among some Michigan farmers that severe thunderstorms that dropped hail on parts of the state will hurt their harvests.   
Suzuki recalls nearly 26,000 cars for fire risk
  July 29, 2014  |  AP  Suzuki is recalling nearly 26,000 midsize cars in the U.S. because the daytime running light modules can overheat and could cause a fire.   

Monday
St. Marys cutting down on germs with futuristic robot
Grand Rapids MI  July 28, 2014  |  WGVU  Cleaning patient rooms is entering a new dimension at Mercy Health St. Mary’s hospital in Grand Rapids.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Founders Bank & Trust partnering with Old National
  July 28, 2014  |  WGVU  Grand Rapids-based Founders Bank & Trust is being acquired by Old National Bancorp.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Meijer LPGA Classic benefits Simply Give program
  July 28, 2014  |  WGVU  The LPGA Tour brings the best players in women’s golf to Grand Rapids for the first time in more than a decade. The inaugural Meijer LPGA Classic takes place August 7-10, at Blythefield Country Club.    
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
AAA Michigan: Gas prices fall 14 cents in week
Dearborn MI  July 28, 2014  |  AP  AAA Michigan says gasoline prices in the state dropped about 14 cents in the last week, the fourth straight week they've fallen.   
Funeral planned for Michigan gas station clerk
Battle Creek MI  July 28, 2014  |  AP   Funeral services will be held for a Battle Creek gas station employee who was fatally stabbed during a robbery.   
Review: Compliance issues in 20 home day cares
Detroit MI  July 28, 2014  |  AP   A review of 20 Michigan home day cares has found each out of compliance with at least one state requirement for children's health and safety.   
Churches hold day of prayer for child immigrants
Grand Rapids MI  July 28, 2014  |  AP  A number of churches in Michigan have joined in a day of prayer for the tens of thousands of child immigrants who have been flooding across the nation's southern border.   
Grand River burn planned to remove invasive plants
Lansing MI  July 28, 2014  |  AP  State officials are planning a series of fires on two islands in the Grand River in Ottawa County to get rid of an invasive, reedy plant called phragmites   
Michigan school chief meets with charter leaders
Lansing MI  July 28, 2014  |  AP   Michigan's schools superintendent will meet with charter school backers as he works to hold institutions accountable for schools they authorize.   
Residents clean up after severe thunderstorms
White Lake Twp MI  July 28, 2014  |  AP  Residents of Michigan's Lower Peninsula are cleaning up after a series of severe thunderstorms that hit Michigan's Lower Peninsula and knocked out power to more than 200,000 homes and businesses.   
Construction begins on Detroit light rail project
Detroit MI  July 28, 2014  |  AP   Construction is starting on a long-awaited commuter light rail project linking downtown Detroit to the city's New Center area.   
Crews work to restore power after severe storms
Highland Twp MI  July 28, 2014  |  AP   Crews are working to restore power after severe thunderstorms hit Michigan's Lower Peninsula and knocked out power to about 223,000 homes and businesses.    
Northern Michigan lawmaker's mom supports opponent
  July 28, 2014  |  AP  State Rep. Wayne Schmidt has picked up support from an unlikely source in a closely watched battle for an open Senate seat in northern Michigan: his opponent's mom.   
Michigan residents asked to respect rattlesnakes
Ann Arbor MI  July 28, 2014  |  AP  Michigan residents have been asked to respect rattlesnakes in light of a recent incident at an Ann Arbor botanical garden.   
Projects in 5 counties fight blight, boost housing
  July 28, 2014  |  AP  The state says projects in five Michigan counties are getting a share of more than $2.5 million to help fight blight and create senior housing.   
Report for Detroit creditor boosts value of art
Detroit MI  July 28, 2014  |  AP  One of the companies challenging Detroit's bankruptcy plan says the possible value of the Detroit Institute of Arts' collection is $8.5 billion - a figure that's higher than previous estimates.    
Possible land deal for US-Canada bridge delayed
  July 28, 2014  |  AP  A proposal has been delayed to transfer 301 Detroit-owned properties to the Michigan Land Bank in exchange for $1.4 million from the Canadian government as part of plans for a $2 billion international commuter bridge.   
Fireworks association plans 2016 Michigan event
  July 28, 2014  |  AP  The National Fireworks Association plans to hold its annual convention in Grand Rapids in 2016.   

Friday
18 residents displaced by apartment fire
  July 25, 2014  |  WGVU  A housing unit on Grand Rapids’ northwest side destroyed by fire Thursday evening has left 18 people homeless. WGVU’s Caroline MacGregor reports.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download
Ex-radio host signs plea deal in child porn probe
Grand Rapids MI  July 25, 2014  |  AP   A former host at a popular Christian radio station in western Michigan plans to plead guilty in a child pornography investigation.   
Fire guts apartment building in Grand Rapids
Grand Rapids MI  July 25, 2014  |  AP   A fire has gutted an eight-unit apartment building in Grand Rapids.   
Michigan DNR offers young hunter workshops
Lansing MI  July 25, 2014  |  AP  Young hunters can get instructions on use of a variety of weaponry and equipment this summer during a series of workshops at state-operated shooting ranges.   
Man arraigned in stab slaying of gas station clerk
Battle Creek MI  July 25, 2014  |  AP  A man has been arraigned on first-degree murder charges in the fatal stabbing of a 27-year-old Battle Creek gas station employee.    
Closing arguments Monday in player's slaying
Ann Arbor MI  July 25, 2014  |  AP   Closing arguments are expected Monday in the trial of a man in the fatal shooting of Eastern Michigan University football player Demarius Reed.   
Group wants probe of absentee voting allegations
Dearborn Heights MI  July 25, 2014  |  AP  An advocacy group says it wants state and federal authorities to investigate allegations that suburban Detroit officials prevented Arab-Americans from obtaining absentee ballots.   
Judge: Detroit mob beating sentences will stand
Detroit MI  July 25, 2014  |  AP  A judge is sticking to light sentences for two men who participated in a mob attack on a Detroit-area motorist in April.   
State Senator ready to revisit creating state-run health exchange
  July 25, 2014  |  MPRN  There could be another push in Lansing to set up a state-run website to purchase insurance through the federal healthcare law. As Jake Neher reports, one state Senator says he’s ready to revisit the idea.   
 Listen    Download Audio File Download

radio
Listen Live to WGVU-AM
Listen Live to WGVU-FM
Follow us on Twitter
WGVU News Page Sponsored by:
Amtrak
 
 
Home    Privacy Policies    Contact WGVU    GVSU.edu    PBS.org    NPR.org
Copyright 1997-2014 | WGVU is a service of Grand Valley State University | GVSU is an EO/AA institution