Patrick Center October 29, 2012 | WGVU While private sector unions like the United Autoworkers or AFL-CIO are regulated under federal law, Proposal 2 would protect Michigan’s public employee’s right to collective bargaining.
“I think it’s really a question of are we in a race to the top economically or a race to the bottom.” Mark Schauer is with Michigan LECET, that’s Michigan Laborers-Employers Cooperation and Education Trust. He says yes to prop 2 because states that have collective bargaining rights do better.
“Those states have better unemployment rates, less poverty, more people covered with health insurance and pensions. And state’s that provide for collective bargaining have median average salaries or income of $8,000 more a year than state’s that have more restrictive collective bargaining law.” Schauer says this is not to say public employees must join unions.
A concern listed at the Mackinac Center for Public Policy’s website is that Prop 2 would give labor unions the ability to repeal many of the reforms that have helped Michigan start to turn the corner after a decade of malaise. Elected representatives would be legislatively powerless to stop them.
While Governor Snyder says he’s not opposed to collective bargaining, in a video he explains the initiative could wipe out a number of different labor laws put in place over the last 50 years.
“If you think about the consequence of wiping out statutes that have been around that long and that many it could be devastating. We’re seeing good economic progress in reinventing Michigan. If this proposal is to pass how much litigation would take place? How much things would come to a standstill and how difficult would it be to move forward.”
Would Proposal two unwind state laws and reforms? Schauer says that’s not true. “Attorney General Bill Schuette claimed that to the Michigan Court of Appeals and to the State Supreme Court. He said that 170 laws would be overturned and that Proposal 2 was overly broad. Those claims were rejected by both courts and by the Supreme Court which is a conservative Supreme Court they rejected that unanimously.”
But there are those who say it’s bad for business. Rick Baker is head of the Grand Rapids Area Chamber of Commerce. He says while the state has a very pro-business economy. “From the outside that’s not the perception and I think this just sets us back and drives a nail even harder into that perception.”
Even though Proposition 2 is about state and local employees, Baker says factor it in with the national stigma Michigan is pro-union and it makes it difficult to recruit new businesses.
For Baker, protecting collective bargaining under the state’s constitution is a bad idea? “If they can get this passed they are set. And they can ignore the legislative process and just go directly to the city council and school board tables and have the constitution standing behind them as they negotiate their future.”
For Mark Schauer, Michigan’s constitution should be amended to include collective bargaining right. “We have seen basic rights that are under the jurisdiction of the state legislature to be systematically chipped away. That’s the crux of the problem.”
684,000 residents signed the petition to place Proposition 2 on the ballot. The final vote comes November 6th.
More WGVU News
Today Settlement to end odors from Detroit incinerator Detroit MI October 21, 2014 | WGVU The state of Michigan says it's reached an agreement with two companies to end odors from a Detroit incinerator as part of a settlement that includes a $350,000 fine.
Wayne State law school plans to freeze tuition Detroit MI October 21, 2014 | WGVU Wayne State University's Law School plans to freeze tuition next year and give a scholarship to every incoming student.
Central Michigan star back Rawls to be sentenced Mount Pleasant, MI October 21, 2014 | WGVU One of college football's top running backs faces sentencing in a Michigan theft case.
Grand Rapids Community College plans buyouts Grand Rapids MI October 21, 2014 | WGVU Grand Rapids Community College plans to offer buyouts to some faculty and staff as part of an effort that could save $5 million over the next decade.
Great Lakes water levels rise to above average Port Huron, MI October 21, 2014 | WGVU The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers in Detroit says water levels in Lakes Michigan and Huron are above average this season for the first time since 1998.
Apple Pay option for West Michigan consumers October 21, 2014 | WGVU This week's launch of Apple Pay gives consumers another way to pay. Will it change the way we shop? ListenDownload Upper Midwest wolf population rises despite hunts VIRGINA, Minn. October 21, 2014 | AP The gray wolf population has increased slightly in the Western Great Lakes District, which includes Minnesota, Wisconsin and Michigan. Michigan doctor sentenced in sexual assault PETOSKEY, Mich. October 21, 2014 | AP A northern Michigan family care doctor who pleaded guilty to sexually assaulting a patient under the pretense of therapy has been sentenced to 38 months to 10 years in prison. Health groups plan Michigan insurance events EAST LANSING, Mich. October 21, 2014 | AP Health advocacy groups are partnering in Michigan to help uninsured residents sign up for health coverage. Democrats slam Snyder over health care contract LANSING, Mich. October 21, 2014 | AP The Michigan Democratic Party is accusing Gov. Rick Snyder's administration of extending a state contract without competitive bidding and increasing its worth a day after the company's executives held a fundraiser for his campaign. Spectrum Health, Pennock enter merger talks GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. October 21, 2014 | AP Spectrum Health and Pennock Hospital in Barry County are entering into merger talks.
Pennock with its 49-bed hospital in Hastings has entered into merger talks with Grand Rapids-based Spectrum Health.
Discussions are underway after Pennock Health’s board of directors signed a non-binding letter of intent.
The Pennock health care system includes eight primary care physician offices, three specialty clinics for women’s health, general surgery, orthopedics, two pharmacies and a health and wellness center.
There are also plans for the construction of a new, $70 million Pennock Hospital near Hastings. If a partnership can be reached, it’s not clear what will become of those plans. Officials there say the creation of a new master facility plan would be necessary to determine whether the new hospital moves forward.
ListenDownload Michigan donors to super PAC include Land's dad LANSING, Mich. October 21, 2014 | AP Republican U.S. Senate candidate Terri Lynn Land's father was among Michigan residents who gave heavily last month to a conservative group that has spent at least $4 million on TV ads against Democrat Gary Peters. Gov. Snyder signs law to ban Tesla direct sales LANSING, Mich. October 21, 2014 | AP Gov. Rick Snyder has signed into law tighter restrictions to prohibit electric car maker Tesla Motors from selling vehicles in Michigan.